0 Show us the money Mr Cunliffe

Posted by Blogger Name. Category: David Cunliffe , David Parker , John Key , Labour Party , Phil Goff , Show me the money , The Two Davids , Treasury , War room

Phil Goff's credibility as Labour leader was blown apart in the "Show me the money" debate in Christchurch in 2011. Here's a reminder in case you've forgotten:

Now, three years later, David Cunliffe is leaving himself and Labour wide open to similar "Show me the money" taunts from John Key and his MP's; 3News reports:

Labour says New Zealanders can have confidence it's getting its numbers right despite dumping a Treasury staff member from their position in the leader's office.

Radio Live revealed a long-standing Treasury secondment has been terminated after a dispute over who should pay their salary.

This now leaves Labour with no independent number-cruncher, but leader David Cunliffe says his office has a strong policy team.

"We have very high grade, quantitative analysis and economic modelling skills in our office," says Mr Cunliffe. "The team is led by the Honourable David Parker, who has my absolute confidence."

Economic Development Minister Steven Joyce says many of Labour's policies don not add up and he is not surprised to hear there has been no input from Treasury.

What has happened here is that Labour has effectively sacked the seconded staff from Treasury, in favour of compiling its own numbers and costing its own policies. In some places that would be called creative accounting.

Pardon our naivety, but we would have thought that having policies independently costed would have been a strong selling point. Instead Labour is going to rely on its own numbers straight from the War Room, and free from any skerrick of independent scrutiny. We can see that working; not!

We reckon that the Two Davids are setting themselves up to fail. But hey; who are we to stop them?

FOOTNOTE: For those readers who aren't familiar with the origins of the "Show me the money" line, check out this video clip which is probably NSFW (not suitable for work); unless you work in Labour's War Room!

Tweet

Komentar →